Table 3 Quasi-imperial 'nation-states': imperial roots and recent crises
|
late modern state |
imperial history |
historic crises |
modern imperial history |
recent crises of empire |
central democratic movements |
quasi-imperial reaction |
outcomes |
|
Russian Federation |
Tsarism |
1917 revolution |
Stalinist Soviet Union and bloc: terror, camps, terror-famines of peasantry, deportations of nationalities, etc. |
Germany 1953, Hungary & Poland 1956 Czechoslovakia 1968, Poland 1981-83, C-E Europe 1988-89, Caucasus, Baltics, 1988-91 |
Gorbachev reforms 1985-91 |
Yelstin/ Putin regimes vs. Chechnya 1994-5, 1999- |
ex-USSR: oligarchic demo-cracies, numerous local wars; E-C Europe: pro-Western democracies |
|
China |
Imperial dynasties; C19 Western penetration |
1912, 1949 revolutions |
Maoism: 'Great Leap Forward' terror famine, 'Cultural Revolution' |
Tibetan resistance 1951-, Xinjiang 1990s |
Tiananmen Square 1989 |
Deng/ military repression 1989- |
economic reform within authori-tarianism |
|
India |
Mogul empire; British Raj |
1947 indepen- dence war |
national parliamentary regime; Kashmir, etc. |
Kashmir, Nagastan, etc. |
? |
Kashmir wars, nuclear weapons |
entrenched elite democracy |
|
Pakistan |
ditto |
ditto |
repeated military dictator-ships |
Bangladesh Kashmir |
mass parties |
Kashmir wars, nuclear weapons |
fragile democracy > military rule |
|
Indonesia |
Javanese empire; Dutch colonial empire |
Japanese war; 1940s indepen- dence struggle |
Javanese domin- ation; pro-Western Suharto regime |
1965 massacres of CP/Chinese; E Timor 1975-99; Aceh, Ambon, etc. 1998- |
1998 student revolt |
1998-: military and para-military repression |
highly unstable democratic reform |
|
Turkey |
Ottoman empire |
early C20 secular national movement |
Armenian genocide; pro-West military regime; repression of Kurds |
PKK war |
leftist movements, democratic Islamist parties |
military repression, anti-Kurdish wars |
limited democratic reform, incomplete pro-EU turn of elites |
|
Yugoslavia |
part of Ottoman empire; early C20 monarchy |
late C19, early C20 Balkan wars; WW2 partisans/ nationalists |
Titoist multi-national state |
Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia, Kosovo independence movements |
Serbian revolution 2000 |
Milosevic repression, genocidal wars 1989-1999 |
unstable compromises of ethnic-national democracies |
|
Ethiopia |
empire |
Italian conquest, restoration |
Selassie, Menghistu regimes |
Eritrean secession-ists |
early 1990s democratic movements |
new Eritrea war 1998- |
new authoritarianism |